No. LV (2024)
Articles

Debating Balkan Commonalities: Is There a Common Balkan Culture?

Slobodan G. Markovich
Faculty of Political Sciences University of Belgrade Belgrade, Serbia

Published 26.12.2024

Keywords

  • ,
  • Balkans,
  • Jovan Cvijić,
  • Balkan civilization,
  • Balkan mentality,
  • Balkanism
  • ...More
    Less

How to Cite

Markovich, S. G. (2024). Debating Balkan Commonalities: Is There a Common Balkan Culture? . Balcanica - Annual of the Institute for Balkan Studies, (LV), 161–184. https://doi.org/10.2298/BALC2455161M

Abstract

Analysing the contributions of Jovan Cvijić, Traian Stoianovich, Paschalis Kitromilides and a range of Balkanologists, the author attempts to summarise the debate on Balkan commonalities and answer if the debate was able to identify shared features that could be seen as a common Balkan culture. The author first deals with the emergence of Balkan studies, which he connects with the spirit of regional cooperation that appeared in the Balkans after 1928. The first efforts to answer the question of Balkan commonalities were made in the seminal work of this discipline on the Balkan Peninsula (1918). In this book, Jovan Cvijić provided evidence for a divided rather than a unified region. The efforts of Traian Stoianovich to define a “Balkan civilization” remained in the borderland between global history and Balkanology. Paschalis Kitromilides provided the most convincing arguments for a Balkan mentality but did not go beyond the early modern period and Balkan Orthodox Christians. In the paper the evolution of the term Balkanism has been analysed to retrace the change of focus in Balkan studies, which lost some its original drive from the 1930s for finding commonalities, instead growing more focused on political and cultural contexts. In the conclusion the importance of the whole debate on Balkan commonalities has been highlighted. Although strong evidence of Balkan commonalities was found only in linguistics, this discussion proved significant for Balkan studies and brought about important results for the discipline.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

  1. Revue International des Études Balkaniques (1934–1938)
  2. The Times (1820s, 1850s, 1918–19)
  3. “Balkan”. In The Encyclopaedia Britannica, The Ninth Edition (Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black, 1875), vol. 3. 282.
  4. Bataković, D. T. “Jovan Cvijić. Balkanologue, géologue et géographe”. In Jovan Cvijić, La Péninsule balkanique. Géographie humaine, 7–23. Belgrade: National Library of Serbia, 2014.
  5. Bogdanović, N. “Balkanizam”. In Srpska enciklopedija, vol. I – 1, 491. Novi Sad and Belgrade: Matica srpska, SANU and Zavod za udžbenike, 2010.
  6. Bourchier, J. D. “Balkan Peninsula”. In The Encyclopaedia Britannica, The Eleventh Edition vol. 3, 258–261. New York: The Encyclopaedia Britannica Company, 1910.
  7. Brailsford, H. N. Macedonia. Its Races and Their Future. London: Methuen & Co., 1906.
  8. Budimir, M., P. Skok. “But et signification des études balkaniques” [“Aim and Significance of Balkan Studies”]. Revue Internationale des Études Balkaniques 1 (1934), 1–28.
  9. Byrnes, R. F., (ed.) Communal Families in the Balkans: the Zadruga. Essays by Philip E. Mosely and essays in his honor. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976.
  10. Clogg, R. “A millet within a millet. The Karamanlides”. In I Kath’inas Anatoli, 387–410. Istanbul: The Isis Press, and River Road: Gorgias Press, 2010.
  11. Coulanges, F. De. The Ancient City. A study on the religion, laws, and institutions of Greece and Rome. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980.
  12. Cvijić, J. La Péninsule Balnanique. Géographie humaine. Paris: Librairie Armand Colin, 1918.
  13. Cvijić, J. “The Geographical Distribution of the Balkan Peoples”. The Geographical Review 5 5 (1918), 345–361.
  14. Cvijić, J. “The Zones of Civilisation of the Balkan Peninsula”. The Geographical Review. 5, 6 (1918), 470–482.
  15. Goldsworthy, V. Inventing Ruritania. The Imperialism of the Imagination. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998.
  16. Goldsworthy, V. Iron Curtain. A Love Story. London: Chatto and Windus, 2022.
  17. Filipović, M. S. “Zadruga (kućna zadruga)”. In Communal Families in the Balkans: the Zadruga, ed. Robert F. Byrnes, 268–279. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976.
  18. Filipović, M. S. “Zadruga (Kućna zadruga)”. In Enciklopedija Jugoslavije, 573–576. Zagreb: Jugoslavenski leksikografski zavod, 1971.
  19. Friedman, V. “Balkans as a Linguistic Area”. In Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics, 657–672. Oxford: Elsevier, 2006, 2nd ed.
  20. Hitchins, K. “Robert Lee Wolff ”. Slavic Review 40, 2 (1981), 336.
  21. Hobsbawm, E. J. Nations and Nationalism since 1780. Programme, Myth, Reality. Cambridge: CUP, 1995, new and rev. ed.
  22. The History of the Times. Vol. III: The Twentieth Century Test 1884–1912. New York: The Macmillan Company, 1947.
  23. Kitromilides, P. “‘Balkan mentality’: history, legend, imagination”. Nations and Nationalism 2 (1996), 163–191.
  24. Kitromilides, P. “‘Balkan mentality’: history, legend, imagination”. In An Orthodox Commonwealth. Symbolic Legacies and Cultural Encounters in Southeastern Europe article I, 163–191. Aldershot: Ashgate Variorum, 2007.
  25. Kitromilides, P. “Orthodox culture and collective identity in the Ottoman Balkans during the eighteenth century”. In An Orthodox Commonwealth. Symbolic Legacies and Cultural Encounters in Southeastern Europe, article II, 131–145. Aldershot: Ashgate Variorum, 2007.
  26. Kostov, A. “Polovin vek Institut na balkanistika” [“Half a Century of the Institute for Balkan Studies”], 2014. Retrieved in September 2024 from: https://balkanstudies.bg/en/struktura/structura.html
  27. Lampe, J. R. “Imperial Borderlands of Capitalist Periphery”. In The Origins of Backwardness in Eastern Europe; Economics and Polities from the Middle Ages until the early Twentieth Century, ed. Daniel Chirot, 177–209. Berkley: University of California Press, 1989.
  28. Malešević, S. Grounded Nationalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019.
  29. Markovich, S. G. “The Legacy of King Alexander I of Yugoslavia”. Balcanica 40 (2009), 201–206.
  30. Markovich, S. G. “Paschalis Kitromilides and the Weak Foundations of National Identity in the Balkans”. In The False Continuity of Nations: Contributions of Paschalis Kitromilides to the Study of the Orthodox Commonwealth and Nationalism in the Balkans, ed. S. G. Markovich, 25–37. Belgrade: Centre for British Studies, 2018.
  31. Markovich, S. G. “European Cultural Transfer in 19th–Century Serbia and how to analyse the Europeanisation of Serbia”. In Cultural Transfer Europe-Serbia. Methodological Issues and Challenges, ed. S. G. Markovich, 45–91. Belgrade: Faculty of Political Science and Dosije Press, 2023.
  32. Mazower, M. The Balkans. A Short History. New York: Modern Library Chronicles, 2000.
  33. Mazower, M. Salonica. The City of Ghosts. Christians, Muslims and Jews 1430–1950. London and New York: Haper Perennial, 2005, 1st ed. 2004.
  34. McNeill, W. H. “A Study in Balkan Civilization”. Journal of Social History 2, 2 (1968), 172–174.
  35. Mead, M. “Introduction: Phlip E. Mosely’s Contribution to the Comparative Study of the Family”. In Communal Families in the Balkans: the Zadruga, ed. Robert F. Byrnes, xvii–xxvii. Notre Dame and London: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976. Merriam-Webster Collegiate Dictionary. Springfield: Merriam–Webster Incorporated, 1998, 10th ed.
  36. Michelson, P. E. “Victor Papacostea and Southeast European Studies in Romania”. Revue des Études Sud–Est Européennes 22 (1984) 359–362.
  37. Obolensky, D. The Byzantine Commonwealth. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1971.
  38. Pavlowitch, S. K. “Europe and the Balkans in a historical perspective, 1804–1945”. Journal of Southern Europe and the Balkans 2, 2 (2000), 141–148.
  39. Reilly, K. “Introduction”. In Balkan Worlds, ed. Traian Stoianovich, xv–xvi. New York: M. E. Sharpe, 1994.
  40. Sandfeld, Kr. Linguistique balkanique: problèmes et résultats. Paris: Libraire Klincksieck, 1930.
  41. Sandfeld, Kr. “Note de syntaxe comparée des langues balkaniques”. Revue Internationale des Études Balkaniques 1 (1934), 100–107.
  42. Schmale, W. “What is Cultural Transfer?”. In Cultural Transfer Europe-Serbia. Methodological Issues and Challenges, ed. S. G. Markovich, 13–31. Belgrade: Faculty of Political Science and Dosije Press, 2023.
  43. Skok, P. and M. Budimir. “Ziel und Bedeutung der Balkanstudien” [“Aim and Significance of Balkan Studies”]. Beograd: Balkanistitut, 1934.
  44. Stanišić, V. “Balkanizmi u srpskohrvatskom jeziku” [“Balkanisms in Serbo-Croat language”]. Balcanica 16–17 (1985–86), 245–265.
  45. Stavrianos, L. The Balkans since 1453. London: Hurst and Company, 2000, 1st ed. 1958.
  46. Stoianovich, T. “The Pattern of Serbian Intellectual Evolution, 1830–1880”. Comparative Studies in Society and History 1, 3 (1959), 242–272.
  47. Stoianovich, T. A Study in Balkan Civilization. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1967.
  48. Stoianovich, T. French Historical Method: The Annales Paradigm. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1976.
  49. Stoianovich, T. Balkan Worlds: The First and Last Europe. Armonk: M. E. Sharpe, 1994.
  50. Srejović, D. “Neolithic Religion”. In The Encyclopedia of Religion, ed. Mircea Eliade, vol. 9, 352–360. New York: Simon Schuster Macmillan, 1993.
  51. Tanasković, D. “Islam na Balkanu” [“Islam in the Balkans”]. In Enciklopedija živih religija, 300–309. Belgrade: Nolit, 1992.
  52. Todorova, M. Imagining the Balkans. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.
  53. Todorova, M. ‘UF Professor Explains How Balkans Got Their Reputation’. Retrieved in September 2000 from: http://www.clas.ufl.edu/CLASnotes/9610/Todorova.html
  54. Trgovčević, Lj. Naučnici Srbije i stvaranje Jugoslavije [Scientists of Serbia and the Creation of Yugoslavia]. Belgrade: Narodna knjiga and SKZ, 1986.
  55. Wolff, R. L. The Balkans in our Time. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1974, 1st ed. 1956.